Table 4 provides bmi's net earnings in GBP million [77] . In 2010, bmi's negative earnings accounted for around -[…]% of its turnover, which is an indication of very substantial losses.
Table 4 : bmi's net earnings 2008-2012 (in GBP million)
2008 |2009 |2010 |2011 (unaudited) |2012 (forecast) |
-[…] | -[…] | –[…] |- […] | –[…] |
Lufthansa considers that bmi's persisting losses result from structural disadvantages: obsolete equipment, lack of a market niche with a respective brand and business model, and structural disadvantages stemming from high airport charges at Heathrow, which are designed to attract long-haul traffic rather than a short/ mid-haul business such as the one operated by bmi.
Lufthansa indicated that as with other Lufthansa affiliates, it had sought to have bmi benefit from synergies with the broader Lufthansa Group, e.g. by joint purchasing and other contracts, joint facilities with other Lufthansa Group companies (e.g. joint maintenance in London), use of other affiliates' services for handling and check-in, and joint marketing in particular with the access to Lufthansa's sales organization like corporate contracts in Germany. It also mentioned its attempts to restructure bmi since it acquired control of it. The first Lufthansa restructuring plan, “bmi Turn-around Plan”, dates back to 2009 and was aimed at downsizing the business, moving the focus from domestic to mid-haul routes, and operating wet leases to Lufthansa. According to Lufthansa, the new focus of mid-haul routes improved the overall cost structure, and the measures were generally considered as a success but were eventually insufficient to trigger a turn-around. [78]
Since the beginning of 2011, bmi has continued to generate significant losses. In May 2011, Lufthansa's management board asked bmi's management to work out a drastic restructuring plan On 24 August 2011, bmi's management presented the core elements of this plan called "Focus bmi" to Lufthansa's management board. bmi's management's proposal was based on four modules designed as separate steps: i) further network downsizing and increased focus on mid-haul routes, ii) increased role as a "production platform" for the Lufthansa group (e.g. through wet lease agreements), iii) specific approach towards domestic UK routes, iv) divestment of surplus slots.
1.1.2. Options considered by Lufthansa