, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
341.

As clarified by the CAA in the context of the market investigation, [177] a EU airline that would be interested in being designated as a UK carrier on any route subject to restrictions (such as London-Cairo) could at any point apply to the CAA and the UK Department for Transport ("DfT") in order to be allocated traffic rights.

342.

Such an application could be lodged also for route rights currently held by another carrier. If in such circumstances the incumbent carrier(s) were not prepared to voluntarily surrender their route rights a situation of “scarce bilateral capacity” would materialize. In such a scenario, the DfT could ask the CAA to reconsider the licences of the incumbent carriers and ask the CAA to hold a "scarce bilateral capacity hearing".

343.

The board of the CAA would at such a hearing decide which airlines should be designated. In making this decision the CAA would take into account the competitive situation and consider which carrier could sustainably provide the most benefit for consumers.

344.

Similarly, in a scenario in which a carrier voluntarily gave up its rights as a designated carrier, the DfT would inform qualifying airlines that the rights to be a UK designated carrier on a route were available. At first, an informal inquiry would take place with those qualifying carriers who have previously expressed an interest in operating a service on that route. If the informal inquiry indicates that other airlines would be interested in operating a route then subsequently a more formal process would take place with qualifying airlines, advised that rights are available. If more airlines are interested in operating the route than there are rights available, the scarce bilateral capacity process outlined above would be triggered.

345.

The UK DfT explained [178] that a scarce capacity situation has occurred recently, when some additional frequencies have been allowed under the UK-Egypt ASA (3 weekly). In the subsequent scarce capacity hearing bmi, IAG and easyJet applied for the additional frequencies and easyJet was successful. The above-mentioned airline was thus recognised as UK designated carrier and granted 3 weekly frequencies. As mentioned above, however, the Egyptian CAA is for the time being blocking easyJet's operations and its traffic rights are unused [179] . The DfT further highlighted that it is currently very difficult to talk to competent authorities in Egypt due to the so called "Arab spring" events.