In Summer 2011, bmi had a higher market share in the TS passenger segment than IAG. bmi's market share is partially caused by Star codeshare passengers on its flights. According to the Parties, passengers travelling on bmi's flights as a result of Star codeshare agreements accounted for around [50-60%] of bmi's passenger share (i.e. over [100,000-150,000] passengers annually).
Since November 2011 however, bmi has stopped operating on the route and the services were taken over by Lufthansa with bmi just putting its code on the Lufthansa flights. As the Star codeshares would be discontinued after the Transaction, the Commission considers it likely that much of the Star codeshare passengers would continue to fly on the Lufthansa operated services.
Bmi's exit and Lufthansa's entry on the route seem directly related to the Transaction. As a result of this exit and entry, the Transaction does not lead to a reduction of the number of competitors operating on the route; on the contrary, Lufthansa already operates on the route in competition with IAG while bmi no longer does.
Lufthansa operates from the same airport as IAG, namely from Heathrow. It operates on the route with three daily flights. IAG (even though the Transaction would not lead to an increment since bmi is no longer operating on the route) would have a frequency advantage over Lufthansa. Nevertheless, Lufthansa's schedule is attractive for both TS and NTS passengers. It will offer morning outbound and evening return flights in both directions, which is an important factor for TS passengers.
In the light of the above, it can be concluded that Lufthansa would exert a significant competitive constraint on the Parties for the TS passenger segment on the London-Berlin route post-Transaction.
The route is also operated by easyJet from Gatwick and Luton, and by Ryanair from Stansted. easyJet has a relatively strong market share in the TS passenger segment (in summer 2011 [20-30]% on a London(three)-Berlin market and [20-30]% on a London(five)-Berlin market), Ryanair less (in summer 2011 [10-20]% on a London(five)-Berlin market). The Parties argued that these are two well established carriers with frequencies that are suitable for a day return between the cities.