It follows from Table 5 that all considered options involved a negative revenue (in other words, a cost) for Lufthansa. […] [87] :
· […]
· […]
[Redacted – Refers to LH Group decision making criteria] [88]
Lufthansa's supervisory board approved these proposals and Lufthansa continued negotiations with both IAG and Virgin.
On the basis of its due diligence investigation, [Redacted – Refers to confidential negotiations with Virgin]. On 22 December 2011, Lufthansa and IAG signed a sale and purchase agreement on the basis of a final offer by IAG [Redacted – Refers to IAG's final offer].
These elements constitute strong indications that if IAG had made no offer, or had proposed a price entailing […], bmi's insolvency would have been Lufthansa's preferred option.
The Commission conducted in-depth analysis to assess the overall consistency of the figures and statements put forward by Lufthansa. For instance, the Commission investigated the magnitude of Lufthansa's trading exposure to bmi on the basis of a report commissioned by bmi to assess the outcome of a possible insolvency scenario [89] as well as various other documents provided by Lufthansa. This analysis confirms the overall consistency of the elements provided by Lufthansa.
It was difficult for Lufthansa to calculate precisely certain relevant parameters for the purposes of comparing the various options, [Redacted – Refers to LH Group decision making criteria]. However, Lufthansa appears to have come to firm conclusions as to how these parameters should be globally quantified in that context, as evidenced by internal documents [90] . Besides, even if some additional value adjustments could have been considered on some cost/revenue items (such as the loss of air transport revenues for Lufthansa), these adjustments are in total not of such a magnitude as to affect the conclusion that Lufthansa considered restructuring far more costly than insolvency, and that Lufthansa would have sold bmi neither to IAG nor to Virgin [Redacted – Refers to LH Group decision making criteria] before the end of 2011. Moreover, all relevant cost/revenue elements appear to have been included in the assessment made by Lufthansa.