Context and analytical framework for the assessment of the Transaction
Competitive situation likely to prevail absent the Transaction
1.1. Most likely situation absent the Transaction
In assessing the competitive effects of a concentration, the Commission compares the competitive conditions that would result from the Transaction with the conditions that would have prevailed absent the Transaction ("counterfactual"). In most cases the competitive conditions existing at the time of the Transaction constitute the relevant comparison for evaluating its effects. However, in some circumstances, the Commission may take into account future changes to the market to the extent that they can be reasonably predicted. It may, in particular, take account of the likely entry or exit of firms if the merger did not take place when considering what constitutes the relevant comparison. [74] In the case at hand, the Commission conducted a prospective analysis to take into account likely developments in the market.
IAG underlined that the effects of the Transaction must be compared against the situation that would have prevailed without the Transaction on a route by route basis and referred to that end to the confidential counterfactual analysis made by Lufthansa. [75] Lufthansa argues that absent the Transaction, bmi would become insolvent and exit all markets since Lufthansa would no longer want to provide financial support to this loss-making company. In this context, Lufthansa argues that bmi meets the criteria of the "failing firm defence" (see Section VII).
1.1.1. bmi's history and attempts to restructure it
Lufthansa acquired control of bmi in 2009 following a "put" option exercised by one of bmi's other shareholders. Since then, bmi has been incurring losses of more than GBP […] per year and Lufthansa has been providing substantial funding to bmi in order to support its operations. Unsecured loans of GBP […] were granted and subsequently converted into equity. Moreover, bmi benefited from capital increases of GBP […] and GBP […] respectively in June 2010 and May 2011. bmi also received GBP […] through the sale of slots at Heathrow to Lufthansa and Swiss, which is part of the Lufthansa group, and GBP […] through loans granted by the Lufthansa group and secured by aircraft and slots [76] .