, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
288.

The market investigation was inconclusive on the question whether flights to Nice from Gatwick, Luton and Stansted are valid substitutes for flights offered from Heathrow. The market investigation was inconclusive on the question whether easyJet offers a credible competitive alternative to the Parties' services for NTS passengers.

289.

From the above it appears that on a Heathrow-Nice route the Transaction would lead the merged entity to a monopoly. The Transaction would still lead to significant market shares on a wider London(three)-Nice market with respect to the NTS passenger segment.

1.4.5. (4) Entry/expansion

290.

Demand currently exceeds capacity throughout most or all of the day at Heathrow. Nice is a slot coordinated airport. However, COHOR, the organisation appointed by the French Authorities to allocate slots at the airport of Nice, indicated that airlines, when adopting their programs for future seasons, almost never encounter difficulties in obtaining the necessary slots. The reason why the airport is coordinated is because there is an important flux of business traffic which is only announced at a late stage. COHOR however does not expect any slot shortages to arise at the airport of Nice for the next seasons.

291.

IAG considers that, given Air France-KLM's strong position at City, it is foreseeable that Air France would launch services on the London-Nice route. However, the press release that IAG sent to the Commission on 26 March 2012 regarding Air France's and easyJet's inauguration of their base at the airport of Nice only refers to Air France's intention to launch new services to Southern Europe, not to London.

292.

No likely, timely and sufficient entry capable of adding significant competitive pressure on the Parties post-Transaction has been identified. If any, new entries and frequency increases post-Transaction would take place from airports other than Heathrow. [170] Therefore, entry would not appear as sufficient to deter or defeat the anticompetitive effect of the Transaction on the London-Nice route.

293.

Contrary to the submission made by the Parties on 9 March 2012, the Commission doubts that the London-Nice route would have been operated by bmi only for a short timeframe. To the contrary, it appears that bmi's internal documents refer to year round operation. This conclusion is not altered by the additional information submitted by the Parties on 23 March 2012.

1.4.5. (5) Conclusion on the London-Nice route