The Parties have submitted market shares for all direct-direct, direct-indirect and indirect-indirect overlap routes. For those routes where their activities overlap on a direct-direct basis, they do not consider further the competitive constraint of indirect/one-stop flights when in aggregate they account for under 10% of travel on the O&D pair.
The question of the substitutability of direct and indirect flights, which is relevant for flights from London to Riyadh and Jeddah, will be examined in the competitive assessment of these routes.
1.1.5. Substitutability of charter flights and scheduled flights
When defining the relevant O&D markets for air transport services, the Commission has previously held that charter flights were not part of the same product market as scheduled flights. [45]
The Parties have only produced market shares both including and excluding charter services for routes on which charter services account for at least 1,000 passengers over the last four IATA Seasons, and in particular for London-Marrakech.
It can be left open for the purpose of this Decision whether passenger air transport services offered on charter flights belong to the same market as passenger air transport services offered on scheduled flights as the conclusion of the competitive assessment remains the same irrespective of the precise market definition.
1.1.6. Substitutability of train transports services with air transport services
When defining the relevant O&D markets for air transport services, the Commission has previously also considered other transport alternatives to the extent that they are substitutable to a flight (intermodal competition). [46] This has been considered in cases where alternative modes of transport on the respective O&D route can be considered comparable in terms of price, quality and (global) travel time and can therefore be considered as valuable alternatives by customers.
The question of substitutability of train transport services with air transport services is relevant in this case for the London-Manchester, London-Edinburg, and London-Aberdeen routes. This issue will be examined on the relevant route by route competitive assessment.