The market investigation showed that IAG was considered by a majority of the competitors, corporate customers and travel agents as bmi's closest competitor. The market investigation was inconclusive with respect to IAG's closest competitor and respondents referred to both bmi and Lufthansa. Easyjet and Ryanair were considered to be more distant competitors. Also, the market investigation showed mixed views amongst the corporate customers and amongst the travel agents as regards the question whether or not easyJet and Ryanair offer a credible competitive alternative for TS passengers. It is thus not clear to what extent easyJet and Ryanair would exert a competitive constraint on the Parties post-Transaction. However, this does not affect the conclusion drawn by the Commission.
Overall, the market investigation showed that a majority of the competitors, travel agents and corporate customers considered that there is sufficient constraint by actual or potential competition on the route so as to prevent IAG from increasing prices post-Transaction.
Considering all the above, it can be concluded that at least Lufthansa would constrain the Parties on the TS passenger segment on the London-Berlin route.
1.4.7. (3) NTS passengers
Looking at the market share data for Summer 2011, the Parties' market shares with respect to the NTS passenger segment vary depending on which London airports are taken into consideration in the relevant market. In particular, the Parties are the only carriers operating on the Heathrow-Berlin route. On a London(three)-Berlin market, which would also include easyJet's flights from Gatwick, the Transaction would lead the merged entity to a combined market share of [50-60]% (with easyJet having a market share of [40-50]%). On a London(five)-Berlin market, which would in addition include easyJet's flights from Luton and Ryanair's flights from Stansted, the Transaction would lead the merged entity to a market share of [30-40]% (with easyJet having a market share of [40-50]% and Ryanair of [20-30]%).
As set out above, Lufthansa has taken over bmi's services on the route. It will offer an attractive schedule from London Heathrow. The Transaction does not result in a decrease of the number of competitors on the route.