, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
93.

The Commission found in earlier decisions that the relevant market in intra-European routes of air cargo transport can be defined as European-wide and should include alternative modes of transport, notably road and train transport. [56] The Parties agree and the market investigation in the present case confirmed this view. [57]

94.

As far as intercontinental routes are concerned, the catchment areas at each end of the route broadly correspond to continents for those continents where local infrastructure is adequate to allow for onward connections (for example, by road, train, or inland waterways), such as Europe. [58] As regards continents where local infrastructure is less developed, the catchment area corresponds to the country of destination.

95.

Concerning routes from Europe to the Middle East, and in particular those from Europe to Saudi Arabia, the market investigation showed that the majority of respondents believes that the relevant catchment area is either the whole Middle East Region or a smaller area including Saudi Arabia and other neighbouring countries such as UAE, Bahrein, Oman and Qatar. [59] This would be due, in particular, to the recent improvements of the local road networks and to free movement agreements entered into by some countries of the region. Some respondents also mentioned that the relevant market definition should include alternative modes of transport, such as freight ships. [60]

96.

In the case at issue it is however not necessary to conclude on the precise scope of the geographic market since no serious doubts arise on the routes from Europe to Saudi Arabia regardless of the market definition adopted.

3.

Groundhandling

3.1. Relevant product market

97.

Aircraft groundhandling refers to the servicing of an aircraft while it is on the ground. It covers a variety of airport services such as ramp services (including aircraft guiding and towing, baggage loading and unloading, freight and mail handling, refueling, de-icing, catering, lavatory drainage, water cartage, cleaning and ground power) and passenger services (including check-in counter services, gate arrival and departure services, transfer counters, customer service and airport lounges).