In the case at issue, the market investigation was not entirely supportive of a specific airport market definition. [67] In the first place, some respondents declared that groundhandling services offered at Spanish airports vary from airport to airport. Other respondents indicated that airlines operating on the Spanish market organize bids to select their groundhandling service provider for several airports, thus contracting with one groundhandling company for all or a number of airports from/to where they operate.
Therefore, it cannot be excluded that the market for groundhandling services in Spain may have a wider geographic dimension encompassing in some cases more than one airport. However, the precise definition can be left open as the Transaction does not raise serious doubts irrespective of the precise geographic market definition adopted.
Maintenance, repair, overhaul ('MRO')
4.1. Relevant product market
With regard to the product market definition, the Commission distinguished in earlier decisions four separate segments within the MRO market, namely (i) line maintenance, (ii) heavy maintenance, (iii) engine maintenance, and (iv) components maintenance. [68]
The Parties agree with the Commission's previously established product market definition and the market investigation confirmed the Commission's view. [69]
The precise scope of the product market definition for MRO services can be left open since the Transaction does not raise serious doubts under any possible product market definition.
4.2. Relevant geographic market
With regard to the geographic scope of the market for MRO services, the Commission has found that heavy maintenance services might be at least EEA-wide, whereas line maintenance could be local in scope [70] and engine maintenance world-wide. [71] With regard to MRO services for components, the Commission considered these services to be world-wide. [72] In recent decisions, the Commission left open the geographic market definition with regard to MRO services. [73]
The Parties submit that the precise scope of the geographic market definition for MRO can be left open as no serious doubts would arise under any plausible market definition.
For the purposes of this Decision, the precise scope of the geographic market definition for MRO can be left open since the Transaction does not raise serious doubts under any geographic market definition.