In view of the relatively limited scope of these Assurances, these leave a very wide margin of freedom to IAG to issue binding recommendations determining the strategic behaviour of IB Opco, in particular in areas such as investment policy, pricing, capacity offered on various routes, annual budget etc.
As a result, in light of IAG's rights to issue binding recommendations to the directors of IB Opco, it is concluded that IAG has the right to manage IB Opco's affairs and that therefore the condition in Article 5(4)(b)(iv) of the Merger Regulation is met.
1.1.2. (3) IAG has the power to exercise more than half of the voting rights in Iberia (Article 5(4)(b)(ii) of the Merger Regulation)
All shares issued by IB Opco Holding [13] carry one vote. IB Opco Holding's shares and voting rights are held as follows:
IAG: 43.1% of the shares and voting rights;
BA: 6.8% of the shares and voting rights; and
the Spanish Nationality Entity: 50.1% of the shares and voting rights.
The Spanish Nationality Entity, as shareholder in IB Opco Holding, is required to exercise its voting rights at shareholder meetings as directed by IAG (provided that the corresponding resolutions are not contrary to the Assurances (see above) and do not result in the corporate structure no longer meeting the nationality requirements). The Spanish Nationality Entity would not be bound to follow IAG’s orders if it considered that voting as directed by IAG would not be in the best interests of the Spanish national shareholders of IAG. If the Spanish Nationality Entity were considering not voting in accordance with an IAG recommendation or direction, IAG may refer the matter to the IAG shareholders. In the event of a vote by IAG shareholders on such a matter, the voting rights of IAG shareholders who are Spanish nationals would be magnified so that they represent a majority of the total voting rights in IAG in relation to that matter (according to the same rules as those foreseen in case of dispute between IAG and the Spanish Nationality Entity in relation to the appointment of the Chairman and CEO).
Paragraph 179 JN provides that the thresholds listed in Article 5(4)(b)(ii) of the Merger Regulation "are also met if the undertaking concerned de facto has the power to exercise more than half of the voting rights in the shareholders' assembly."