, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
98.

With regard to the product market definition, the Commission considered in earlier decisions that groundhandling services can be divided into distinct segments on the basis of either the International Air Transport Association ("IATA") Standard Ground Handling Agreement or the EU Directive on groundhandling services, [61] but the determination of whether each segment constituted a separate relevant market was left open. [62] In other previous decisions the Commission examined possible alternative product market definitions but finally left the precise definition open. [63]

99.

The Parties agree, and the market investigation in this case confirmed, that the relevant product market for the provision of groundhandling services encompasses both passenger and aircraft handling. Indeed, while some market players indicated that a narrower market could be identified for specific services like aircraft re-fueling and catering or according to the contestable or non-contestable nature of the services considered, the majority of the respondents in the market investigation considered that groundhandling services include passenger and baggage registration, handling and leading the aircraft on the ground as well as aircraft cleaning and refueling. [64]

100.

Therefore, for the assessment of the present Transaction, the relevant product market definition for the provision of groundhandling services encompasses both passenger and aircraft handling.

3.2. Relevant geographic market

101.

The Commission considered in previous decisions that the geographic scope for the provision (or contracting) of groundhandling services was restricted to a specific airport given that the services required at a particular airport could not normally be substituted by services provided at other airports. The Commission therefore concluded that the relevant geographic market for the provision of groundhandling services was the area of a specific airport but ultimately left the question open. [65] The Commission also considered that a wider geographic market could be defined encompassing other airports within a catchment area that could attract airlines if groundhandling service providers were present at those airports. [66]

102.

The Parties argue that the Commission does not need to reach a firm conclusion on the geographic market as, regardless of market definition, the Transaction will not give rise to serious doubts.