The replies to the market investigation indicate mixed views as to whether the existing competitors on the route constitute a credible competitive alternative to the Parties' services on this route. While slightly more respondents (competitors, corporate customers, travel agencies) answered that the current competitors constitute a credible alternative to the Parties' services on this route, there was also a considerable number of respondents which did not believe that the competitor's services are credible competitive alternatives Furthermore, most of the respondents considered that there is no sufficient constraint by actual or potential competition on the market so as to prevent IAG from increasing prices post-Transaction. Lastly, almost all respondents to the market investigation (competitors, corporate customers and travel agents) indicated that IAG and bmi are each other's closest competitor.
Therefore, the Parties would face no competitive constraint on a Heathrow-Aberdeen market and they would only face limited constraints from FlyBe on London(three)-Aberdeen on the TS passenger segment. Even on a London(five)-Aberdeen market, easyJet and FlyBe do not appear to exert a significant competitive constraint on the Parties on the TS passenger segment.
1.4.1. (3) NTS passengers
The Parties' market shares vary significantly depending on which airports in the London area are taken into consideration in the relevant market.
In particular, if the relevant market is limited to Heathrow-Aberdeen, the Transaction leads to a monopoly with an increment of [20-30]%, based on the Summer 2011 IATA season data.
If the relevant market is London(three)-Aberdeen, the Parties' combined market share would be [50-60]% (with an increment of [10-20]%) and the remaining competitors would be FlyBe and easyjet which would have market shares of [10-20]% and [20-30]% respectively.
If the relevant market is London(five)-Aberdeen, the Parties combined market share would be [40-50]% (with an increment of [5-10]%). easyJet appears to be a significant competitor on the NTS market on the London(five)-Aberdeen market, with a market share of [40-50]%. Flybe would have a market share of [10-20]%.