In addition, in 2011, bmi's critical financial situation required its directors to defer the filing of the 2010 statutory accounts, as a going concern declaration on a stand-alone basis would have required a "comfort letter", i.e. a guarantee by Lufthansa to cover bmi’s losses for the next financial year. […] [91] The signing of a term sheet and later the conclusion of a sale and purchase agreement with IAG allowed bmi to submit its accounts on a “going concern” basis only a few days prior to the possible commencement of criminal prosecution against its directors. This indicates that Lufthansa was keen to leave the insolvency option open until an agreement could be reached with a potential buyer.
[Redacted – Refers to measures adopted by bmi's management and Lufthansa] This confirms that insolvency was seriously considered by Lufthansa.
Therefore, the Commission considers that absent a sale of bmi to IAG, bmi would likely have gone insolvent and, as a consequence, would have exited the market quickly afterwards. [92]
[Redacted – refers to analysis of sale negotiations] [93] [94] [95]
Considering in addition that the cost of restructuring was by far higher than the cost of insolvency [Redacted – refers to analysis of sale negotiations], the Commission is of the view that in the absence of a firm offer by IAG [Redacted – Refers to LH Group decision making criteria], Lufthansa would have decided in favour of the insolvency scenario.
To conclude, the pre-Transaction situation is not likely to be sustainable absent the Transaction. Following a detailed analysis of the arguments put forward by the Parties, the most likely situation absent the Transaction would be an immediate/very short term insolvency. In view of bmi's limited cash balance at the end of 2011 (GBP […]), bmi would very likely stop operations at the beginning of the insolvency proceedings. Indeed, bmi would have quickly lacked all the vital inputs necessary to its business such as fuel, access to airports or aircraft maintenance. Therefore, the Commission considers that the relevant comparison to assess the effects of the Transaction in this case is with a scenario where bmi would have exited all markets.