, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
230.

In view of all what precedes, even if train services are part of the relevant product market on this route, they appear to be at best a distant substitute for air services from the perspective of TS passengers. Therefore, in spite of its theoretical [20-30]% market share on the all-passenger market, East Coast trains and train services in general appear to exert only a limited competitive constraint on the Parties on the TS passenger segment.

1.4.2. (3) NTS passengers

Competition from air services

231.

The Parties' market shares vary significantly depending on which airports in the London area are taken into consideration in the relevant market.

232.

In particular, if the relevant market is limited to Heathrow-Edinburgh, the Transaction leads to a monopoly with an increment of [40-50]%, based on the Summer 2011 IATA season data.

233.

If the relevant market is London(three)-Edinburgh, the Parties' combined market share would be [70-80]% (with an increment of [10-20]%). The other competitors would be easyJet with a market share of [20-30]% and Air France with a market share of [0-5]%.

234.

If the relevant market is London(five)-Edinburgh, the Parties' combined market share would be [50-60]% (with an increment of [10-20]%). easyJet appears to be a significant competitor on the NTS market on the London(five)-Edinburgh market, where it has a market share of [30-40]%. Air France only has a share of [0-5]%.

235.

The market investigation confirmed that existing competitors on this route constitute a credible competitive alternative to the Parties' services on the NTS passenger segment on this route. A slight majority of the respondents (competitors, travel agents, corporate customers) also considered that there is a sufficient constraint by actual or potential competition on the market so as to prevent IAG from increasing prices post-Transaction on the NTS passenger segment.

Competition from train services

236.

As concerns competition from train services, since the main competitive disadvantage of train relates to travel time, train is likely to exert more competitive pressure on the Parties on the NTS passenger segment than on the TS passenger segment.

237.

The majority of respondents to the market investigation (competitors and travel agents) indicated that 10% or more passengers would switch to train in case of a price increase of air fares on the London-Edinburgh route.