, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
88.

The market investigation in the present case showed that a wider market may exist as, unlike passengers, cargo may be routed with a higher number of stopovers and therefore any indirect/one-stop route is a substitute for any direct/non-stop route. [48] While some market players argued that a separate market could be identified including only direct flights used to transport specific goods (such as time-sensitive products, fruit and vegetables, live animals, pharmaceuticals, valuables, etc.), the majority of the respondents indicated that such a distinction is not material. [49]

89.

With regard to cargo service operators, the market investigation confirmed that there is no reason to sub-segment the market according to the type of the provider as the four types of air cargo carriers, namely (i) cargo airlines with dedicated freighter planes; (ii) airlines with only belly space cargo capacity on passenger flights; (iii) combination airlines (i.e. airlines with both dedicated freighter airplanes and belly space cargo capacity); and (iv) integrators, [50] compete with each other for business with the same kinds of customers. [51]

90.

In addition, as established in previous Commission decisions, air cargo transport markets are inherently unidirectional due to differences in demand at each end of the route and must hence be assessed on a unidirectional basis. [52] This was confirmed by a large majority of respondents in the market investigation. [53]

91.

In previous cases, the Commission left open the question whether the market for air cargo transport should be further sub-divided according to the nature of the goods transported (for example, dangerous or perishable goods). [54] The Parties submit that no sub-segmentation according to the type of cargo should be made. The market investigation revealed that the majority of respondents (customers and competitors) agreed with the Parties that the cargo markets should not be segmented in this way. Indeed, nearly all cargo transporters declared that they carry all kinds of cargo in the same aircrafts. [55] Several respondents also pointed to the use of standardized packaging and to the fact that no different handling is required for loading and unloading.

92.

Therefore, the competitive assessment in this case will be based on the market for air cargo transport that includes all kinds of transported goods.

2.2. Relevant geographic market