In view of the above, irrespective of the precise market definition (Heathrow-Manchester or London (three)-Manchester), train constitutes a significant constraint on the Parties on the TS passenger segment. The Parties would only have a combined market share of [5-10]% on the all-passenger market including flights from Heathrow and Gatwick and train services, with Virgin trains having the remaining [90-100]% of the market. Therefore, their market share on the TS passenger segment is likely to be even lower.
1.4.3. (3) NTS passengers
Assuming that the relevant market comprises only air services, the Parties' market shares do not vary significantly depending on which airports in the London area are taken into consideration in the relevant market – the Transaction would lead to a monopoly with an increment of [20-30]% on a Heathrow-Manchester market and to a monopoly with an increment of [10-20]% on a London(three)-Manchester market based on the Summer 2011 IATA season data.
However, considering the above analysis of the TS passenger segment, train is very likely to exert a competitive constraint on the Parties also on the NTS passenger segment on the London-Manchester route. This is consistent with the fact that the majority of the respondents to the market investigation (competitors, travel agencies) expressed the view that more than 10% of NTS passengers would switch to train should air fares increase on this route.
1.4.3. (4) Conclusion on the London-Manchester route
Considering the above, the Transaction does not give rise to serious doubts as to its compatibility with the internal market as regards the London-Manchester route.
1.4.4. London-Basel
1.4.4. (1) Description of the route
In the Winter 2010 and Summer 2011 IATA seasons, a total of [350,000 – 400,000] O&D passengers travelled by air between London(three) and Basel [164] . Among them, [150,000 – 200,000] passengers travelled between Heathrow and Basel. Over the same period, transfer passengers accounted for [20-30]% of all passengers flying between London(three) and Basel. That ratio was [30-40]% for passengers flying between Heathrow and Basel.
IAG estimates that [30-40]% of O&D passengers on the London(three)-Basel route were time sensitive over the same period and that this ratio is [40-50]% for O&D passengers that travelled between Heathrow and Basel.