During the market investigation, Virgin [96] claimed that he Transaction should be assessed against the position which existed prior to IAG's recent acquisition of six daily slot pairs from bmi, which was announced in September 2011, six weeks before IAG announced that it has reached an agreement in principle for the acquisition of bmi. According to Virgin, it would be wrong to assess the Transaction by reference to the situation which existed as at the date of announcement of the Transaction.
The Commission considers that this approach is incorrect. Indeed, the acquisition of six daily slot pairs by IAG from bmi and the Transaction are not interdependent. The transfer of these six slots took place even before a sale and purchase agreement was signed by IAG and Lufthansa. Moreover, since Lufthansa took its decisions as regards the future of bmi in December 2011, it appears clearly that in the counterfactual, absent an offer by IAG [Redacted – Refers to LH Group decision making criteria] bmi would not have become insolvent before December 2011. It would have become insolvent only after the transfer of the six daily slot pairs to IAG. Virgin's argument must thus be dismissed [97] .
1.2. Consequences of bmi's market exit – reallocation of slots at Heathrow
Pursuant to Article 8 (2) and 10 (2) of Council Regulation (EEC) No 95/93 of 18 January 1993 on common rules for the allocation of slots at Community airports [98] (hereafter: "the EU Slot Regulation"), a carrier holding a slot series in a given scheduling season is entitled to retain the same series in the next equivalent scheduling season if it can demonstrate to the slot coordinator that the series of slots has been operated for at least 80% of the time during the scheduling period for which it has been allocated for the operation of scheduled and programmed non-scheduled air services. This is referred to as the "use-it-or-lose-it" rule.