, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
238.

Therefore, it appears that train is likely to exert at least some constraint on the Parties on the NTS passenger segment, despite the fact that the Parties would face no competitive constraint on a Heathrow-Edinburgh market from other air carriers.

1.4.2. (4) Entry/expansion

239.

Demand currently exceeds capacity throughout most or all of the day at Heathrow and Gatwick. On the contrary, Luton, Stansted, City and Edinburgh are not slot constrained.

240.

IAG submits that easyJet, which has a base in Gatwick, Luton, Stansted and Edinburgh and Air France, which has a new base at Edinburgh and a base at City, would likely further increase their frequencies on this route. Other potential new entrants could be according to IAG, Ryanair, Jet2, Aer Lingus, Air Berlin and the potential buyer of bmi Regional (Granite).

241.

No likely, timely and sufficient entry capable of adding significant competitive pressure on the Parties post-Transaction has been identified. If any, new entries and frequency increases post-Transaction would take place from airports other than Heathrow. Therefore, entry would not appear as sufficient to deter or defeat the anticompetitive effect of the Transaction on the London-Edinburgh route.

1.4.2. (5) Conclusion on the London-Edinburgh route

242.

The effects of the Transaction on the London-Edinburgh route must be compared against the situation that would have prevailed on this route without the Transaction. As set out above in Section V.1, the Commission considers that, absent the Transaction, bmi would have exited this route and that IAG would likely have been more threatened by new entry on this route than in a post-Transaction scenario.

243.

Therefore, and in view of the limited competitive constraint that would be expected to be exerted on IAG on the London-Edinburgh route post-Transaction, the Transaction gives rise to serious doubts as to its compatibility with the internal market as regards the London-Edinburgh route.

1.4.3. London-Manchester

1.4.3. (1) Description of the route