The Parties also refer to a number of papers recently prepared in the UK with respect to the various London airports. They first refer to the UK Competition Commission's final report on the BAA Airport Market Investigation. [32] In 2009, the UK Competition Commission investigated the effect on competition of the common ownership by BAA of seven UK airports, including the three London airports Heathrow, Gatwick and Stansted. In the context of its analysis, the Competition Commission looked amongst others at the question of substitutability of the three London airports. Evidence it found suggested a "significant substitutability of passenger demand between the BAA London airports, with significant overlaps between their catchment areas, although to an extent that varies between different categories of passenger". [33] It also found that Heathrow, Gatwick and Stansted are exposed to each other's catchment area to a significant degree (which is higher than their exposure to the catchment areas of Luton and London City). Also, it referred to passengers' surveys that suggested that passengers regard Heathrow, Gatwick and Stansted as better alternatives for each other than non-BAA airports (the only possible exception to this is whether Stansted or Luton is, after Gatwick, the next best alternative to Heathrow). These surveys also showed a relatively low passenger sensitivity to fare increases (83 to 91 per cent of passengers would not switch in response to a £5 increase in air fares). It found that airlines operating routes from Heathrow considered that their main competitors tended to operate from the same airport. It finally noted that "As regards terminating passengers, airlines had a range of views, but a number made the point that Heathrow was preferred to Gatwick by many passengers, in particular business passengers".
They further refer to a recently published working paper of the CAA, [34] analysing the catchment areas of Heathrow, Gatwick, Luton and Stansted [35] under three different angles: (i) it defined the airports' catchment areas in function of surface travel time to the airport; (ii) it looked at data about the districts from which passengers originated and (iii) it looked at the geographic distribution of actual airport usage. All three approaches suggested that there was a considerable extent of catchment area overlap between Heathrow, Gatwick, Luton and Stansted.