, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
148.

Therefore, one difference between the counterfactual and the post-Transaction situations relates to the distribution of slots at Heathrow. In absence of the Transaction, the likelihood that other carriers than IAG may acquire part of bmi's substantial slot portfolio at Heathrow and enter routes where IAG would be in a monopoly or dominant position becasuse bmi's exit, or routes where supply would be significantly reduced following bmi's exit, would be higher than in the post-Transaction situation, where the entirety of bmi's slot portfolio would be controlled by IAG. Indeed, post-Transaction, due to the heavy congestion prevailing at Heathrow, entry opportunities would remain strongly limited by the scarcity of slots whereas in absence of the Transaction, entry barriers would be lowered by the reallocation of most of bmi's substantial portfolio between various carriers, through reallocation via the pool, slot sales (probably more marginally), an,d permanent transfer to lessees (in the case of slots leased out to third parties).

149.

Other airports from which bmi currently operate in competition with IAG are much less congested than Heathrow. Therefore, the detrimental impact of the Transaction on slot availability for IAG's competitors, assessed by comparison to the counterfactual, is of much more limited importance for these other airports than for Heathrow, which is also bmi's main base.

150.

The fact that slots can be – and are actually – traded at Heathrow does not affect the magnitude of the effects of the Transaction concerning the availability of slots at Heathrow as assessed by comparison to the counterfactual. Asked whether they could obtain necessary slots at Heathrow through purchases or leases in order to launch hypothetical new services, a majority of respondents to the market investigation that took a clear position on this question replied that they could not or that it would be either difficult or dependent on the requested timing [117] . Moreover, assuming that enough slots would be available on the secondary or lease market to satisfy all requests, the price itself may constitute a barrier under normal conditions [118] . A respondent to the market investigation noted in this respect that "slots at a commercially viable price are not available from the pool or in the market."