If the relevant market is London(three)-Edinburgh, the Parties' combined market share would be [80-90]% (with an increment of [10-20]%) and the other operators would be easyJet with a market share of [10-20]% and Air France with a market share of [0-5]%.
If the relevant market is London(five)-Edinburgh, the Parties' combined market share would be [50-60]% (with an increment of [10-20]%). easyJet would have a market share of [40-50]%. The other remaining competitor on this market is Air France which has a market share of [0-5]%.
On a combined basis, the Parties enjoy a significant frequency advantage over easyJet and Air France even on a London(five) market (26 compared to 12). For the time being, due to its limited number of frequencies, Air France currently exerts limited competitive constraint on the Parties.
A slight majority of respondents to the market investigation (competitors, travel agents, corporate customers) considered that existing competitors on the route constitute a credible competitive alternative to the Parties' services on this route, however there was a considerable number of respondents which considered the opposite, i.e. that the existing operators do not constitute a credible competitive alternative to the Parties. Furthermore, most respondents (competitors, travel agents, corporate customers) considered that there is no sufficient constraint by actual or potential competition on the market so as to prevent IAG from increasing prices post-Transaction. Lastly, almost all respondents to the market investigation (competitors, corporate customers and travel agents) indicated that IAG and bmi are each other's closest competitor on the TS passenger segment.
Competition from train services
Train does not appear to exert any significant competitive constraint on the Parties' air services on the TS segment on the London-Edinburgh route.
First, as regards travel duration and round trips. The Parties submit themselves that the average city centre to city centre journey times between London and Edinburgh are longer on train, 265 minutes on direct train vs. minimum 156 minutes by plane for travel. Moreover, round-trips by train involve a total travelling time of around 9 hours, that is to say around 4 more hours than by plane. This seems hardly compatible with all-day meetings.