, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force

IAG |1 |7 |1 |7 |

bmi |1 |7 |1 |7 |

Egyptair |2 |11 |2 |11 |

Source: Form CO

1.4.8. (2) TS passengers

352.

As shown above, on the Heathrow-Cairo route IAG and bmi had a combined market share for TS passengers of [70-80]% in Summer 2011. As far as closeness of competition is concerned, the results of the market investigation suggest that, although a significant number of respondents indicated that bmi exerts a constraint on IAG, the majority of respondents indicated that Egypt Air is the closest competitor of IAG on the TS passengers' market segments. [183]

1.4.8. (3) NTS Passengers

353.

On the NTS passengers' segment, IAG and bmi had a combined market share of [30-40]% in Summer 2011. In addition, the results of the market investigation as regards closeness of competition suggest that the majority of respondents indicated that Egypt Air is the closest competitor of IAG on the NTS passengers' market segment.

1.4.8. (4) Entry/expansion

354.

The market investigation has confirmed that the existing UK-Egypt bilateral restrictions represent a barrier to entry/expansion on flights between the two above-mentioned countries.

355.

In the current situation, the traffic rights that are necessary to operate on the London-Cairo route could be obtained after lodging an application with the UK CAA and DfT asking for the re-allocation of rights currently allocated to other carriers. In the event that these other carriers disagree to release their rights, the "scarce capacity" procedure described above would be triggered, whose outcome largely relies on the appreciation of the CAA's board and cannot be predicted ex ante.

356.

An additional barrier to operate on the route would be the current policy of the Egyptian CAA, which requests for the time being carriers to operate flights with two cabins. In any event, easyJet would under current conditions fly from Gatwick and have only three weekly frequencies on the route. Therefore, it would not represent a sufficient constraint post-Transaction for TS passengers.

357.

On the UK side, a significant barrier to entry/expansion is represented by the scarcity of slots at several London airports and particularly at Heathrow, which is viewed as not sufficiently substitutable with other London airports by a significant number of respondents in the market investigation especially for TS passengers.

1.4.8. (5) Conclusion on the London-Cairo route