, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
139.

As regards Heathrow, the market investigation unambiguously confirmed that this airport is heavily congested, which means that available slots are insufficient to satisfy airlines' demand. In that context, in case of bmi's exit from the market, all the slots currently held by bmi would be very likely to be taken up, be it through sale (probably to a marginal extent), re-allocation via the pool, transfer to IAG in the case of the security slots, or permanent transfer in the case of slots leased out to third parties. Moreover, a significant proportion of bmi's slots at Heathrow would be likely to end up with other carriers than IAG [106] , unlike in the post-Transaction scenario where IAG would indirectly take control of all these slots, with the exception of slots leased out to third parties for so long as the lease agreement applies.

140.

Several respondents to the market investigation indicated that if absent the Transaction bmi were to exit the market in the short term, they would consider entering some of the routes out of Heathrow exited by bmi. UK domestic and European short-haul routes were specifically mentioned. The fact that a relatively large portfolio of slots at Heathrow would be made available either through sale / lease or, probably to a far larger extent, through reallocation via the pool (in total, around 5% of all slots) would significantly facilitate the implementation of such entry plans.

141.

Should bmi be able to sell / lease out slots, some of these slots may be acquired by IAG but there is no reason to believe that it would be the case for all or even a significant part of them. Indeed, according to data provided by IAG, a number of airlines other than IAG acquired slots at the Heathrow and Gatwick airports through purchases or leases between the summer 2008 and winter 2011 IATA seasons, including companies of the Lufthansa group, Delta, Aegean Airlines, United Continental Holding, Flybe, and Aer Lingus [107] . This indicates that IAG is not the only airline ready to pay for the acquisition of scare slots at the most congested London airport. This was confirmed by ACL which mentioned as potential buyers not only IAG but also Virgin, and US and Gulf carriers [108] .