The Parties finally refer to a report published in January 2012 by the UK CAA, setting out its initial view of market power of Heathrow, Gatwick and Stansted. [36] This report indicates that "for passengers travelling on direct services, Heathrow appears to be competing over a relatively broad geographic area, extending to include the South East and Greater London regions, and extending towards the west and north, particularly when attracting passengers to long-haul services. Consequently, there are very significant overlaps in the airport's catchment area with Gatwick, Stansted and Luton (amongst other smaller airports), although many passengers appear to have a strong preference for using services at Heathrow".
These various reports, even though they do support that there is indeed a certain degree of overlap between the catchment areas of the various London airports, are as such not sufficient to conclude whether or not flights offered from these various airports are substitutable for passengers travelling on specific routes. [37] Moreover, the CAA found in its 2011 passenger survey [38] that only 10% of short-haul passengers at Heathrow would be willing to switch away from Heathrow to another airport in light of a £5 (single ticket) / £10 (return ticket) price increase. [39] . The CAA noted in this respect that "Overall, passengers at Heathrow appear to be the least willing to switch in response to an increase in price. This is perhaps not unexpected, as Heathrow has the largest proportion of passengers travelling for business reasons, who may be less price sensitive and may be more likely to travel under a corporate contract. Further, since prices at Heathrow are typically higher than at other London airports (with the possible exception of London City), Heathrow passengers responding to this question would have already revealed themselves as perhaps having a relatively high willingness to pay (albeit for a possible higher perceived service quality at the airport). (…) By contrast, approximately 20% of short haul passengers at Gatwick and Stansted would be willing to switch away from their current airport in light of a price increase, suggesting that they could be more price responsive than their Heathrow counterparts".