Total |16 |107 |13 |99 |
LHR-ABZ |
IAG |7 |46 |6 |44 |
Bmi |5 |37 |5 |38 |
Total |12 |83 |11 |82 |
Source: Form CO [141]
IAG also pointed to the long term competitiveness of train services on this route. They referred to the possibility of avoiding overnight hotel charges in London (and/or Aberdeen) but still being able to spend a full day in Aberdeen/London by travelling on the Caledonian Sleeper services operated by First ScotRail (i.e. travelling during the night and arriving early in the morning in London or Aberdeen). The duration of the train services on this route is 10 hours and 21 minutes, compared to an estimated city centre-to-city centre duration of air travel of a minimum of around 160 minutes [142] . Train services would unlikely constrain the Parties on this route on any of the passenger segments.
1.4.1. (2) TS passengers
The Parties' market shares vary depending on which airports in the London area are taken into consideration in the relevant market. In particular, if the relevant market is limited to flights between Heathrow and Aberdeen, the Transaction leads to a monopoly with an increment of [20-30]%, based on the Summer 2011 IATA season data.
If the relevant market is London(three)-Aberdeen, the Parties' combined market share would be [80-90]% (with an increment of [10-20]%) and another remaining operator would be Flybe with a market share of [10-20]%. Given their limited presence at Gatwick, easyjet appears to have only marginal TS passengers on the market London(three)-Aberdeen. If the relevant market is London(five)-Aberdeen, the Parties' combined market share would be [70-80]% (with an increment of [10-20]%) and the remaining competitors would be FlyBe and easyJet which would have market shares of [10-20]% and [10-20]% respectively.
On a combined basis, the Parties enjoy a clear frequency advantage over FlyBe and easyJet even on a London(five)-Aberdeen market (12 compared to 5) and more significantly on a London(three)-Aberdeen market (12 compared to 4). Furthermore, FlyBe's and easyJet's schedules appear to be less suitable for TS passengers.