, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
249.

Train services are available on the London-Manchester route. Virgin trains offer over 45 daily services each way leaving approximately every 20 minutes. There are significantly more trains running on the London-Manchester city-pair than there are total air frequencies (17 daily air frequencies on average in the Winter 2010 and Summer 2011 IATA seasons). The quickest [155] journey time for travel by train between London and Manchester is 118-127 min [156] and 130 min at minimum by plane from Heathrow. [157] If Virgin trains' services are included in the relevant market, the market shares of the Parties and their competitors on the all-passenger market would be as follows [158] :

Table 13: London-Manchester market shares air services and train services

2009 annual pax |pax |% share |

IAG |[300,000-350,000] |[5-10]% |

bmi |[100,000-150,000] |[0-5]% |

Combined |[400,000-450,000] |[5-10]% |

Virgin trains |[4,300,000-4,350,000] |[90-100]% |

TOTAL |[4,700,000-4,750,000] |100% |

Source: Form CO based on CAA and MIDT data and National Rail Trends 2009-2010 Yearbook

1.4.3. (2) TS passengers

250.

Assuming that the relevant market comprises only air services, the Parties' market shares vary only insignificantly if account is taken of the two possible market definitions. The Transaction leads to a monopoly on all possible markets with an increment of [5-10]% if the market comprises Heathrow-Manchester and [0-5]% if the market is defined as London(three)-Manchester.