The only competing airline post-Transaction would be easyJet, operating from Gatwick, Luton and Stansted. However, the market investigation was inconclusive on the question whether flights from Gatwick, Luton and Stansted are valid substitutes for flights offered from Heathrow, in particular with respect to TS passengers. Also, the Parties' combined number of weekly frequencies is significantly higher than easyJet's (especially considering that bmi meanwhile substantially increased its weekly frequencies to Nice). The market investigation showed mixed views among the travel agents and corporate customers with regard to the question whether or not easyJet offers a credible competitive alternative to the Parties' services. easyJet is a low cost carrier, offering a different service level, flying to a different airport and offering significantly less frequencies. For the reasons set out above, easyJet appears to be only a distant competitor to the Parties, in particular in the TS passenger segment. This conclusion is not altered by the additional information submitted by the Parties on 23 March 2012.
A majority of the competitors, travel agents and corporate customers that responded to the market investigation considered that IAG is the closest competitor to bmi. Their responses with respect to the question who is IAG's closest competitor did not allow drawing clear conclusions.
From the above it appears that on a Heathrow-Nice route the Transaction would lead the merged entity to a monopoly. Even on a wider London(three)-Nice market, the Transaction would still lead to high market shares.
1.4.5. (3) NTS passengers
The Parties' market shares with respect to the NTS passenger segment vary depending on which London airports are taken into consideration in the relevant market. In particular, on a Heathrow-Nice route, the Transaction would lead the merged entity to a monopoly. On a London(three)-Nice market, which would also include flights offered by easyJet from Gatwick, the Transaction would lead the merged entity to a [50-60]% combined market share based on the Summer 2011 IATA season data (easyJet [40-50]%). On an even wider London(five)-Nice market, the Transaction would lead the merged entity to a market share of [30-40]% in the Summer 2011 IATA season data (easyJet [60-70]%). However, as set out above, the market share data provided for bmi are not representative given that bmi only recently started operating.