, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
302.

At first sight, the market share of Austrian with respect to the TS segment seems low ([5-10]% on a Heathrow-Vienna route and [5-10]% on a London(three)-Vienna market. However, Austrian's market share is understated: Austrian codeshares on bmi's flights and its corresponding market share has been included in bmi's share. Passengers travelling on bmi's flights as a result of Star codeshare arrangements accounted for about [50-60%] of bmi's share (i.e. over [30,000-35,000] passengers annually). If these passengers would instead be included in Austrian's market share, it increases to [10-20]% for TS passengers and bmi's share would accordingly reduce to [10-20]%. As these codeshare relationships would be terminated as a result of the Transaction, it seems likely that much of the share accounted for by Star codesharing would switch to Austrian.

303.

In Summer 2011, Austrian operated out of Heathrow with 3 daily frequencies. In addition, Austrian will offer an additional daily service in Summer 2012 using a Heathrow slot that it already owns, thus increasing its daily frequencies from 3 to 4. On a combined basis, the Transaction would provide to the merged entity with a frequency advantage over Austrian. Nevertheless, Austrian's frequencies are attractive for TS passengers, with morning outbound and evening return flights in both directions, which is an important factor for TS passengers.

304.

The market investigation gave strong indications that Austrian is considered as a credible competitive alternative for TS passengers to the Parties' services by competitors, travel agents and corporate customers. Furthermore, Austrian was considered to be IAG's closest competitor by a majority of the competitors, travel agents and corporate customers.

305.

In light of the above, it can be concluded that Austrian would exert a significant competitive constraint on the Parties for the TS segment on the London-Vienna route post-Transaction.

306.

In Summer 2011, easyJet operated out of Gatwick with 1 daily frequency only which does not seem convenient for time-sensitive customers. The market investigation showed mixed views amongst the competitors, corporate customers and travel agents as regards the extent to which easyJet offers a credible competitive alternative for TS passengers. However, this does not affect the conclusion drawn by the Commission.