, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
613.

Importantly, the discussions about the fate of bmi held at Lufthansa board level indicate that costs related to "reputational damage" and "domino effects" were taken into account; these costs are relevant at group level. This also demonstrates that for the purpose of the Commission assessment, bmi should be regarded as a Lufthansa division rather than as a separate entity.

614.

However, the qualification of failing firm or of failing division does not appear to have any bearing on the assessment by the Commission in this case because the requirements for a failing firm defence do not appear fulfilled irrespective of this qualification.

2.

bmi's exit from the market and alternative purchaser

615.

As explained in Section V.I, the most likely situation absent the Transaction is bmi's exit from all markets. This is due in particular to the absence of a credible purchase offer by Virgin.

3.

Asset exit

616.

One of the cumulative criteria laid down in the Horizontal Guidelines to accept a failing firm defence is that absent the merger, "the assets of the failing firm would inevitably exit the market" (emphasis added).

617.

The main assets of bmi are the 56 slot pairs the carrier holds at Heathrow. In case of insolvency, and due to the severe congestion affecting Heathrow, all bmi's slots would be reallocated to other carriers, most likely via the slot pool managed by the slot coordinator. Nothing would prevent carriers obtaining such slots to use them on the routes where they are currently used by bmi. Therefore, these assets would not "inevitably" exit the market.

618.

In addition, slots are not route-specific assets. They must be held by the carrier in order to operate but could in general be transferred between routes [265] . This specificity has to be taken into account in the assessment of whether slots would be likely to exit the market.