However, the data available to the Parties are based on the CASS and World ACD databases, which have a market coverage of 60% and 40% respectively and therefore underestimate the total market sizes and, as a consequence, overestimate the Parties’ market shares.
The Parties' market shares are likely to be further overestimated since the market investigation confirmed that the relevant market of intra-European routes of air cargo transport can be defined as European-wide and should include alternative modes of transport, in particular road and train transport. In any event, the Parties' combined market share on a narrower definition of the market is not significant ([10-20]% in value and [10-20]% in volume) and there will remain numerous competitors active on the market post-Transaction.
In light of the foregoing, the Commission considers that the Transaction does not raise serious doubts on the market for intra-European routes of air cargo transport.
As regards inter-continental routes, according to the Parties the Transaction gives rise to only one affected market, namely air transport of cargo to Europe from Saudi Arabia, in which the Parties' combined market share is [20-30]%, with bmi accounting for approximately [0-5]%.
As noted above, however, the Parties’ combined market share on this route is likely to be overestimated due to incomplete total market data. Moreover, there will remain a number of alternative credible suppliers capable of imposing a significant competitive constraint on the Parties on the route at issue, such as Saudi Arabian Airlines (which also operates long-haul freighter aircraft in addition to using capacity in the belly-hold of its passenger aircraft), Etihad, Qatar, Emirates, Lufthansa Cargo, Air France/KLM, and Turkish Airlines.
The market investigation confirmed the existence of alternative credible suppliers in the affected route that would act as a competitive constraint on the merged entity. [243] A large majority of respondents also considered unlikely the possibility that the Parties could increase prices following the Transaction [244] and indicated that IAG is not the closest competitor of bmi on the routes from Saudi Arabia to Europe and the same is true for bmi with respect to IAG. [245]