In addition, a further competitive constraint on the merged entity is posed by cargo carriers and freight forwarders, which appear to exert considerable countervailing buyer power because of their size and importance. Indeed, the market investigation confirmed that cargo carriers enjoy greater flexibility with regard to schedules and the use of alternative airports and therefore that indirect flights should be included in the relevant cargo market. [246]
Finally, the market investigation confirmed that cargo customers could easily switch to other suppliers at limited costs and within a short time frame post-Transaction and that IAG and bmi do not enjoy any competitive advantage vis à vis their competitors. [247]
4.3. Conclusion
In view of the above, the Transaction does not raise serious doubts as to its compatibility with the internal market with respect to the market for air cargo transport services.
Groundhandling
5.1. Situation absent the Transaction
As far as the market for the supply of groundhandling services is concerned no serious doubts arise irrespective of the scenario used as counterfactual.
5.2. Horizontal relationships
IAG provides groundhandling services to third Parties at several airports located in Spain, Tel-Aviv (Israel), Malabo (Equatorial Guinea) as well as at London Heathrow.
bmi provides groundhandling services to third Parties at certain UK airports (London Heathrow, Edinburgh, Glasgow and Manchester). It also currently provides intra-group groundhandling services to other airlines within the Lufthansa Group (Lufthansa and Austrian Airlines).
In light of the above, the Transaction would lead to only one minor horizontal overlap between the Parties (namely groundhandling at London Heathrow). However, the Parties’ combined share would be below 15% regardless of the product and geographic market definition and therefore the Transaction does not lead to serious doubts about its compatibility with the internal market in this respect.
5.3. Vertical relationships
There are no existing supplier/customer relationships between the Parties to the concentration, as IAG does not provide any groundhandling services to bmi and bmi does not provide any groundhandling services to IAG.