, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force

Washington DC |Virgin |[10-20]% |

Cape Town |South African Airways |[30-40]% |

Cape Town |Virgin |[5-10]% |

Johannesburg |South African Airways |[20-30]% |

Johannesburg |Virgin |[20-30]% |

550.

In a number of cases, this percentage can be very significant, illustrating the important role played by the potentially foreclosed competitor in the competitive process on the route. In such cases, foreclosure on the part of IAG by raising the costs of the foreclosed rival or reducing the number of passengers it carries is likely to weaken that competitor, lessen the competitive constraint it exerts on IAG, and eventually bring prices up on the route.

3.3.4. Conclusion

551.

The Transaction may lead IAG to engage in a foreclosure strategy consisting in restricting access to flights (or raising the costs of that access) for passengers connecting at Heathrow to services operated by other carriers in competition with IAG on various long-haul routes. Such a strategy is likely to have a detrimental impact on prices on these long-haul routes. However, such a strategy is unlikely to be implemented and to have significant detrimental effect on competition and prices in the case of competing carriers that have a hub at one end of the route. Therefore, the Transaction raises serious doubts as to its compatibility with the internal market.

4.

Cargo

4.1. Situation absent the Transaction

552.

As far as the market for the air transport of cargo is concerned, no serious doubts as to the compatibility of the Transaction with the internal market arise irrespective of the scenario used as counterfactual.

4.2. Horizontal relationships

553.

IAG’s cargo business includes British Airways World Cargo (British Airways' cargo airline carrying freight, mail and courier traffic) and Iberia Cargo (Iberia’s cargo division). These businesses use capacity in the belly-hold of passenger aircraft and on three long-haul freighter aircraft. bmi’s cargo business is limited to the use of capacity in the belly-hold of its passenger aircrafts.

554.

As far as intra-European routes for air cargo are concerned the Parties estimate that their combined market share in 2010 was [10-20]%, with bmi accounting for [0-5]%, calculated on the basis of a market definition of intra-European routes excluding alternative means of transport such as road and train.