As already indicated, there are a number of routes where the Parties' combined market shares (taking into consideration only Heathrow at the London end of the route) are high or even equal to 100%. In addition, there are a number of routes where bmi currently faces no competition, or faces competition by a carrier which does not provide feeder traffic at Heathrow. The Commission considers that post-Transaction, a foreclosure strategy affecting such routes could result in foreclosing all rivals on relevant downstream markets (e.g. all carriers offering indirect journeys on the Aberdeen-Los Angeles O&D via Heathrow could be foreclosed in view of the Parties' position on the Aberdeen-Heathrow route). This could result in significant price increase for such indirect journeys.
Moreover, in view of the importance of the aggregate feeder traffic brought by bmi alone and / or by the Parties together to certain carriers for certain long-haul routes out of Heathrow, a foreclosure strategy significantly reducing such feeder traffic (or increasing the costs incurred to keep this feeder traffic) is likely to have detrimental consequences on these long-haul routes out of Heathrow. Indeed, in certain cases, carriers that could be foreclosed by IAG appear to play an important role on such long-haul routes out of Heathrow. If these carriers were severely affected by foreclosure on the part of IAG, the competitive constraint that they would exert on other carriers active on the routes in question (including IAG) may be significantly reduced, bringing prices upwards.
Table 41 sets out for various routes listed in table 39 the share of total passengers travelling on the route carried by various airlines which could be potentially foreclosed by IAG [242]
Table 41: % of passengers carried by potentially foreclosed competitors on various long-haul routes out of Heathrow (summer 2011 IATA season)
Route |Carrier |% |
Calgary |Air Canada |[40-50]% |
Montreal |Air Canada |[40-50]% |
Toronto |Air Canada |[50-60]% |
Vancouver |Air Canada |[30-40]% |
Chicago |United / Continental |[20-30]% |
Chicago |Virgin |[5-10]% |
Houston |United / Continental |[40-50]% |
Los Angeles |Air New Zealand |[10-20]% |
Los Angeles |United / Continental |[5-10]% |
Los Angeles |Virgin |[20-30]% |
New York (all airports) |Virgin |[20-30]% |
New York (all airports) |United / Continental |[10-20]% |
San Francisco |United / Continental |[20-30]% |
San Francisco |Virgin |[20-30]% |