, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
536.

As already indicated, IAG and bmi's feeder traffic provided to certain carriers for certain long-haul routes (in particular the routes listed in table 39 above) can be significant. Control by IAG over such a significant portion of the total number of passengers carried by a competitor on a given route is likely to incentivise IAG to engage in a foreclosure conduct as such a conduct can be expected to have a significant impact on the profitability of this competitor and its ability to exert competitive constraint on IAG on the route.

537.

The incentive to foreclose depends on the degree to which foreclosure would be profitable. IAG is expected to take into account how the provision of access to its flights for connecting passengers would affect its profits on that upstream market, but also its profits on the downstream air passenger transport market. IAG would face a trade-off between the profit lost in the upstream market due to a reduction of input sales to (actual or potential) rivals and the profit gain, in the short or longer term, from expanding sales downstream or, as the case may be, being able to raise prices to consumers. The trade-off is likely to depend on the level of profits the merged entity obtains upstream and downstream. Other things constant, the lower the margins upstream, the lower the loss from restricting input sales. Similarly, the higher the downstream margins, the higher the profit gain from increasing. [237]

538.

IAG provided margin data for a range of UK domestic short-haul and international long-haul routes. These data show that the margins for international long-haul routes are at least around [1-10] times higher than on UK domestic routes. This suggests that if it undertook a foreclosure strategy on a given route, even a small number of passengers diverted away from a competitor onto one of its long-haul flights (compared to the number of passengers lost on short-haul flights as a result of foreclosure) would make foreclosure profitable.