, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
539.

As an illustration of the alleged benefits that IAG could expect from such a foreclosure strategy, Virgin brought forward an analysis of a "natural experiment", namely, bmi's exit from the Heathrow-Glasgow route in March 2011. Virgin considered various international destinations and for each of them, assessed the number of passengers that switched from indirect journeys from Glasgow to the international destination in question with legs respectively operated by bmi and a competitor of IAG, to indirect journeys with both legs operated by IAG. Virgin concluded in substance that should such a switch have resulted from foreclosure instead of bmi's exit, it would have made foreclosure profitable in view of the number of passengers that switched and Virgin's estimates for margins on short-haul and long-haul routes.

540.

In order to assess IAG's incentives to engage in a foreclosure strategy, it could be necessary to take into consideration the possibility that certain passengers may switch from services via Heathrow (e.g. Aberdeen-Los Angeles via Heathrow) to services via other hubs (e.g. Aberdeen-Los Angeles via Amsterdam). Such passengers would not be diverted away to IAG's services. IAG provided data illustrating that the ends of the various routes operated by bmi from Heathrow were well connected to a range of other European and non-European hubs. [238]

541.

Moreover, IAG provided data on the proportion of connecting passengers travelling respectively via Heathrow and other European or non-European hubs on given city-pairs with an end in the UK or Ireland (e.g. Edinburgh-San Francisco). According to IAG, those data show that in many cases, Heathrow is not the most common connection airport [239] . However, the Commission analysed these data and found that for several of these city pairs, more than two thirds of the passengers travel via Heathrow. This constitutes an indication that at least in these cases, a foreclosure strategy leading to price increases for indirect journeys via Heathrow offered by IAG's competitors, may not trigger a major switch of customers to indirect services via other hubs but may rather entice a large proportion of passengers to switch to IAG's services.