, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
468.

First, for the three routes, it is noted that a large majority of the respondents in the market investigation indicated no significant barriers to entry for airlines wishing to operate on the above-mentioned routes and did not make reference to the congestion of airports at either end of the routes as a possible problem in this respect.

469.

Concerning the competitive situation on the Edinburgh-Copenhagen route, bmi Regional offers direct services and IAG offers indirect services. The number of passengers on this very thin route, including all sales, was [0-50,000] in the winter 2010 and summer 2011 IATA seasons combined. The percentage of passengers flying one-stop was approximately [10-20]% and [20-30]% in the time sensitive market segment in the summer 2011 and winter 2010 IATA seasons respectively and about [10-20] % in the non-time sensitive segment both in the summer 2011 and winter 2010 IATA seasons.

470.

The combined market share of the Parties in the summer 2011 IATA season was [60-70]% in the TS market segment. The combined market share of the Parties in the summer 2011 IATA season was [70-80]% in the NTS passenger segment. At least three credible competitors would remain active post-Transaction both in the time sensitive and in the non-time sensitive segment, namely Norwegian Air Shuttle, [211] which offered direct services in recent seasons, as well as KLM/Air France and Lufthansa, which have offered indirect services.

471.

As regards the Glasgow-Copenhagen route, bmi Regional offers direct services and IAG offers indirect services. This route is very thin and therefore does not appear to allow for more than one direct service. Indeed, the total number of passengers on this route, including all sales, was [0-50,000] in the winter 2010 and summer 2011 IATA seasons combined. Among these, [30-40]% and [40-50]% flew one stop in the non-time sensitive market segment in the summer 2011 and winter 2010 IATA seasons respectively and [30-40]% and [40-50]% flew indirect in the time sensitive market segment in the summer 2011 and winter 2010 IATA seasons respectively. The combined market share of the Parties in the summer 2011 IATA season was [70-80]% in the TS passenger market segment. The combined market share of the Parties in the summer 2011 IATA season was [80-90]% in the NTS passenger market segment. In the previous IATA season the Parties' market share was [80-90]%.