Several competitors would remain active post-Transaction both in the TS and in the NTS segment. In particular, KLM has offered indirect service in recent seasons and would remain as credible competitor on this route. SAS also offers indirect services via London Heathrow.
Concerning the Manchester-Lyon route, the overlap between the Parties' activities arises because bmi Regional offers direct services on this city-pair and IAG offers indirect services. This route is very thin and therefore does not allow for more than one direct service. Indeed, a total of 11,056 passengers flew on the route at issue in the winter 2010 and summer 2011 IATA seasons combined. Among these, [50-60]% and [50-60]% flew one stop in the non-time sensitive passengers market segment in the summer 2011 and winter 2010 IATA seasons respectively and [30-40]% and [60-70]% flew one stop in the time sensitive market segment in the summer 2011 and winter 2010 IATA seasons respectively.
The Parties' combined market share in the summer 2011 IATA season was [60-70]% in the TS passenger segment. In addition, the increment brought about by the Transaction would be below 1% in the summer 2011. The Parties' combined market share in the summer 2011 IATA season was [50-60]% in the NTS passenger segment. At least four carriers would exert a credible competitive constraint on the Parties post-Transaction both on the time sensitive and on the non-time sensitive segment, namely Air France/KLM as well as Swiss, Lufthansa and Brussels Airlines, which have offered indirect service in recent IATA seasons.
1.7.5. Conclusion on direct/indirect overlap routes
As a conclusion, the Transaction does not raise serious doubts as to its compatibility with the internal market with respect to the direct-indirect overlap routes identified above.
1.8. Indirect/indirect overlaps
The activities of the Parties also overlap on five short-haul routes where both operate one-stop flights, i.e. Venice-Edinburgh; Geneva-Glasgow; Edinburgh-Nice; Manchester-Naples; Newcastle-Nice.
On the routes Venice-Edinburgh and Newcastle-Nice the Transaction would bring about a very limited market share increment (below 3%) irrespective of the market segment considered.