, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
463.

The increment post-Transaction is between [0-5]% and [0-5]% in the NTS segment on the Manchester-Prague and Edinburgh-Brussels routes in the last two seasons. On the Birmingham-Stuttgart and Birmingham-Hamburg routes the increment in the summer 2011 was [5-10]% and [10-20]% respectively (and below 1% in the previous season), however the Parties' combined market share did not exceed [20-30]% on the former route and barely exceeded [30-40]% on the latter route. In addition, several credible competitors would remain active on both routes. (including FlyBe, Lufthansa, Air France/KLM, Swiss) Similarly, on the Manchester-Milan route, the increment post-Transaction was [5-10]% in the summer 2011 (and below 3% in the previous one), but the Parties' combined market share did not exceed 25%. On the Manchester-Lisbon route, the increment post-Transaction would be [5-10]% having regard to the winter 2010 IATA season (and below 3% in the subsequent one). However, the Parties' combined market share was slightly above 25% in that season.

1.7.3. Edinburgh-Stockholm

464.

As regards Edinburgh-Stockholm, the Parties' combined market share in the TS passengers segment dropped from [50-60]% in winter 2010 to [30-40]% in summer 2011, with a [5-10]% post-Transaction increment. In addition, the merged entity would face significant competition post-Transaction from credible competitors, such as Norwegian Air Shuttle, which offers direct flights on the route, as well as SAS and Air France/KLM, which offer indirect flights.

465.

The Parties' combined market share in the NTS passenger segment decreased from [60-70]% in the winter 2010 to [40-50]% in the summer 2011, with an increment post-Transaction of [5-10]%. The merged entity would face significant competition post-Transaction from credible competitors, such as Norwegian Air Shuttle, which offers direct flights on the route, as well as SAS and Air France/KLM, which offer indirect flights.

466.

The market investigation confirmed the conclusions summarized above, since no respondent highlighted the existence of any problem whatsoever on the nine routes at issue.

1.7.4. Edinburgh-Copenhagen; Glasgow-Copenhagen; Manchester-Lyon

467.

The activities of the Parties result in three additional direct/indirect overlaps on short-haul intra-European routes: Edinburgh-Copenhagen; Glasgow-Copenhagen; Manchester-Lyon.