, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

Finally, it has to be recalled that the protection which is granted to different agricultural products is principally decided by political and not administrative action.

The Commission was of the opinion that, after thorough assessment, the complainant had been informed correctly and sufficiently about the matter.

The complainant's observations

In his observations, the complainant maintained his complaint.

The Decision

The question raised by the complaint was whether the Commission had wrongly interpreted the provisions governing the tariff applicable to deer meat.

The relevant Common Customs Tariff states that deer meat, even when it is not hunted can be declared as "game". It appeared therefore that the Commission had rightly assessed the relevant provisions and that deer meat of animals which remain in captivity can be imported into the Union as game. However, it shall be recalled that the Court of Justice is the highest authority on questions of Community law.

On the basis of the Ombudsman's inquiries into this complaint, there appeared to have been no maladministration by the Commission. The Ombudsman therefore closed the case.

COMMISSION DECISION NOT TO INITIATE INFRINGEMENT OF THE PROCEEDINGS UNDER ARTICLE 169 OF THE EC TREATY

Decision on complaint 175/97/JMA against the European Commission

The complaint

In February 1997, Mr D. complained to the Ombudsman on behalf of his client Mr P., alleging that the Commission had failed to ensure the correct application of Directive 91/533/EEC in Portugal.

Mr P. had been working for the firm "Casinos do Algarve", which was taken over by an Administrative Commission set up by the Portuguese authorities. Following a labour-related dispute, Mr P. brought a legal action against his employer. However, the administrative agency in charge of Casinos declared in Court that it was not responsible for the firm's management. The situation appeared to contravene the criteria laid down in Directive 91/533/EEC, which regulates the employer's obligation to inform employees of the conditions applicable to the contract or to the employment relationship.

Mr P. took the case to the Portuguese courts. Since the case was related to the application of a Community Directive by the Portuguese authorities, he also sent a complaint and several letters to the Commission. Mr P. complained that none of his letters had received a reply from the Commission.

The inquiry

The Commission's opinion

  • celex=31926D0097
  • celex=31986R3529
  • celex=31991L0533
  • celex=31992R3904