The Stromeinspeisegesetz entered into force on 1 January 1991. It imposes on electricity supply companies an obligation to purchase electricity generated from renewable energy sources and to pay a guaranteed minimum price depending on the nature of the renewable source. Article 3(2) of the law prescribes the minimum price of electricity generated from wind power to be 90 % of the average revenue per kWh of electricity which the supply companies generated by sale of electricity in the penultimate calendar year.
The German authorities notified the Stromeinspeisegesetz to the Commission in 1990 as a State aid, in accordance with Article 93(3) of the EC Teaty. The Commission decided that the law was compatible with the common market under Article 92(3)(c).
On 25 October 1996, Commissioner Van Miert wrote to Minister Rexrodt proposing the reduction of the minimum price for wind power energy from 90 % per kWh to 75 % per kWh.
Taking the complaints sent to the Ombudsman as a whole, there were in substance two allegations:
Commissioner Van Miert was not entitled to send the letter in question, because the Stromeinspeisegesetz had been approved by the Commission in a binding Decision under Article 92(3)(c) of the EC Treaty. The complainants considered that the contents of the letter amounted to an alteration of the Commission Decision which may only be made by way of another Commission decision.
Commissioner Van Miert had wrongly assessed the legal and economic situation of wind energy producers in Germany because the Commissioner had apparently based his position only on data and figures provided by the German electricity suppliers, without verifying whether these figures were correct. According to the complainants, the effects of the Commissioner's proposal would be disastrous for the wind energy producers, as the reduction of the remuneration level would jeopardise wind energy plants and with them, the current employment situation. Research in this field would also suffer and this would consequently have a negative impact on the environmental and technical developments. Competition in fact would be distorted and a monopolistic structure would arise.
The inquiry
The Commission's opinion
The complaints were forwarded to the Commission. In summary the Commission's opinion made the following points: