, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999
–

hypothetically, if the institutions abandoned the general principle of recruiting personnel at the basic grade, recruitment on a more appropriate grade might not be justified, and, therefore might create distortions within the personnel with negative effects on motivation and good management,

–

it can be envisaged that older A 8 and A 7 officials more rapidly request promotions in order to obtain a grade which would suit their experience,

–

rules governing age limits are not laid down mechanically, but vary according to the nature of the department's needs and allow a distinction to be made between candidates to take account of their respective situations,

–

unofficially, it has often been mentioned that the use of an age limit is a means of limiting the number of candidates, and therefore in practice age limits enable the organising of "manageable" competitions.

4.2. The Ombudsman was concerned that the grounds for the setting of age limits put forward by the different Community institutions appeared not to be objectively justified in order to eliminate the possibility of arbitrariness. Therefore, without sufficient justification, the setting of age limits could constitute discrimination.

5.

Union citizens' possibility to seek employment within the European Union administration

5.1. The Ombudsman is of the view that each Union citizen should have the possibility to seek employment within the European Union administration. If it is considered appropriate to limit this possibility, this needs to be carried out with sufficient justification, avoiding in the recruitment procedures any elements which might be considered discriminatory or arbitrary.

5.2. The Ombudsman's own initiative inquiry into age limits, as well as individual complaints, have clearly indicated that the Community institutions have applied various age limits without a common justification, either in their practice or in the provision of the Staff Regulations governing the setting of an age limit.

6.

Correct application of age limits

  • celex=31993D0731