The Ombudsman's inquiries revealed that, currently, there is no common constitutional or legal principle in the Member States either allowing or prohibiting age limits. An age limit is imposed on the public sector in more than half of the Member States. However, this age limit is, in general, higher than 35 years. Furthermore, a tendency towards abandoning age limits as discriminatory is apparent in some Member States.
Application of age limits within the Community institutions
3.1. All Community institutions apply age limits for the admission of candidates to competitions. This possibility is mentioned in Article 1(g), of Annex III to the Staff Regulations which provides that the notice of competition must specify: "where appropriate, the age limit and any extension of the age limit in the case of servants of the Communities who have completed not less than one year's service".
3.2. Article 27(2), of the Staff Regulations provides that: "Officials shall be selected without reference to race, creed or sex".
3.3. The Ombudsman understood that, based on Article 1(g) of Annex III to the Staff Regulations, the Appointing Authority may specify an age limit in notices of competition.
3.4. However, the Ombudsman found that taking into account the principle that decisions must be reasoned and the provision laid down in Article 27 of the Staff Regulations, the wording of Article 1(g), of Annex III of the Staff Regulations, in particular, the phrase "where appropriate" and the Court's consistent case-law on the general principle of equality, these seemed to suggest that age limits cannot be imposed arbitrarily and that there should be reasoning to support why a specific age limit is considered appropriate for a particular competition.
3.5. The developed practice indicates that the Appointing Authorities have applied various age limits differing from one institution to another. Article 31 of the Staff Regulations lays down a principle according to which candidates are to be recruited at the basic grade. Therefore, in general, an age limit of under 35 years has been set on the grounds that the basic grades are only suitable for young graduates who, in time, can establish careers as European civil servants.