, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

"Document 5143/1/97 is a note from the General Secretariat containing a compilation of replies of the Member States to a questionnaire on the implementation of the aforementioned Joint Action. This compilation has not yet been examined by the relevant working party, and the report mentioned in the Joint Action has not yet been drawn up.

Having balanced your interest in gaining access to the document against the interest of the Council in maintaining confidentiality of its deliberations, the Council has concluded that the latter interest outweighed the former in this particular case, in accordance with Article 4(2) of the Decision.

Indeed, disclosure of this document at this stage could hamper the scheduled discussions of the matter and could have negative effects on the functioning of the exchange of such information in the future."

As regards "CIREA/1452", the Council stated:

"Having balanced your interest in gaining access to this particular document against the interest of the Council in maintaining the confidentiality of its proceedings, the Council has concluded that the latter interest outweighed the former, in accordance with Article 4(2) of Decision 93/731/EC.

This document, which contains detailed information about the functioning of CIREA, has not yet been examined nor approved by the Council. The Council considers that disclosure of this document at this stage could hamper the planned discussions on this matter."

As regards 'Asylum/8418' and 'Racism/7141', the Council stated that disclosure of the two documents would undermine the protection of public interest under Article 4(1) of Decision 93/731/EC.

In his complaint to the Ombudsman, the complainant claimed that the above reasoning was inadequate.

Furthermore, as a separate allegation he claimed that in reply to the initial application for documents, the Council had failed to balance the interests of citizens in openness against the Council's interest in imposing confidentiality. The complainant submitted that under Decision 93/731/EC this balancing, which is required by the case law of the Community courts, must take place in the reply to the initial application for access to documents as well as in the reply to the confirmatory application which may be submitted following an initial rejection.

  • celex=31993D0731
  • celex=31916D0097