, The European Ombudsman - Annual Report 1998

In forcesince 18 Oct 1999

Given that this aspect of the case concerned procedures relating to specific events in the past, it was not appropriate to pursue a friendly settlement of the matter. The Ombudsman therefore closed the case.

ACCESS TO DOCUMENTS

Decision on complaint 634/97/PD against the Council

The complaint

In July 1997, Mr P. made a complaint to the Ombudsman against the Council. By letter of 19 February 1997 to the Council, the complainant had requested copies of various agendas of Council committees and other documents. The Council rejected parts of the complainant's application, relying on the rules of its Decision 93/731/EC on public access to Council documents(90).

As regards the agendas, the Council informed the complainant that it had decided to provide him with copies of agendas covering a period of six months instead of two and a half years as requested by the complainant. This decision was reached on the basis of Article 3(2) of Decision 93/731/EC which provides that the Council shall find a "fair solution" to deal with repeat applications and/or those which relate to very large documents. The complainant contested the legality of that decision, arguing that Article 3(2) could not apply to a large number of documents, but could only be applicable in respect of separate documents which were "large"; according to the complainant, none of the separate agendas would be longer than about three pages.

As regards the other documents, the Council refused access to the following:

–

"Schoolchildren/5143", a document compiling Member States' replies to a questionnaire on the application of a Joint Action of 1994 on "travel facilities within the EU for schoolchildren who are third-country nationals",

–

"CIREA/1452", a draft report with detailed information on CIREA's activities 1994 to 1996(91),

–

"Asylum/8418", consisting of two documents containing detailed answers from Member States to a questionnaire on asylum principles and practices,

–

"Racism/7141", a note on racist crimes from a Council working group on terrorism.

In refusing access, the Council had communicated the following statements of reasoning to the complainant.

As concerned "Schoolchildren/5143", the Council stated:

  • celex=31993D0731