Mr P. L. initially complained to the Regional Ombudsman of Valencia ("Sindic de Greuges de la Comunitat Valenciana"), who transmitted the complaint to the European Ombudsman.
Mr P. L. took part in a competition for temporary agents organised by the OHIM in November 1995. After a preliminary screening of all the applications, the Selection Board did not admit him to the oral tests, informing him of this in a standard letter.
In April 1996, Mr P. L. wrote to the OHIM, underlining that he was not complaining against the decision taken by the Selection Board, but rather requesting further information on the selection process and the reasons for his exclusion.
The reply from OHIM was considered by the complainant to be very general and to lack any clear reasoning.
The inquiry
The OHIM's opinion
The complaint was forwarded to the OHIM. In its opinion, the OHIM pointed out that the competition was not a general competition for the recruitment of EC officials, but only a selection of temporary agents for secretarial posts (C grade). Accordingly, there are no general rules governing the organisation of this type of special competition for temporary agents. According to the OHIM, the selection process was carried out with due respect for the principles of equal treatment, transparency and geographical balance.
There were four stages in the process: (a) the OHIM sent an application form to all those who expressed their interest to participate; (b) out of 726 applications forms sent, 393 replies were received and registered. Out of those applications, 255 dossiers were considered admissible; (c) the Selection Board then carried out a comparative analysis of the candidates' merits and their experience. Only 75 candidates were included in the final list; (d) the last stage consisted of an oral test.
The complainant was not selected for the oral tests because of his limited professional experience, since he had only worked for the Spanish local administration.
Having completed the recruitment procedure, the Selection Board sent a letter to all candidates informing them of the outcome. Non-selected applicants who had submitted formal complaints were informed of the reasons for their exclusion.
The Office also stressed that the complainant did not contest his exclusion by the Selection Board, but merely inquired about the reasons for the decision. Consequently, his letter had not been considered as a complaint.