, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force

1.4.13. (4) Entry/expansion

442.

The UK/Saudi Arabia Air Services Agreement (ASA) limits frequencies to 35 per week between the UK and Saudi Arabia. The Department for Transport in the UK clarified that these frequencies correspond to a cap on all flights operated by UK designated carriers between the UK and any airport in Saudi Arabia. At present, the following frequencies are operated by UK carriers: 13 frequencies by IAG to Riyadh, 5 frequencies by IAG to Jeddah, 3 frequencies by bmi to Jeddah and 3 frequencies by bmi to Dammam, i.e. 24. There are thus available frequencies on the routes to Saudi Arabia under the UK/Saudi Arabia ASA. However, demand currently exceeds capacity throughout most or all of the day at Heathrow.

443.

No likely, timely and sufficient entry capable of adding significant competitive pressure on the Parties post-Transaction has been identified. Therefore, entry would not appear as sufficient to deter or defeat the anticompetitive effect of the Transaction on the London-Riyadh route.

1.4.13. (5) Conclusion on the London-Riyadh route

444.

The effects of the Transaction on the London-Riyadh route must be compared against the situation that would have prevailed on this route without the Transaction. As set out above in Section V.1., the Commission considers that, absent the Transaction, bmi would have exited this route and that IAG would likely have been more threatened by new entry on this route than in a post-Transaction scenario.

445.

Therefore, and in view of the limited competitive constraint that would be expected to be exerted on IAG on the London-Riyadh route, the Transaction gives rise to serious doubts as to its compatibility with the internal market as regards the London-Riyadh route on the TS passenger segment.

1.5. Direct / direct overlap routes by virtue of bmi codeshare relationships

446.

There are 47 routes on which the Transaction would lead to an overlap due to bmi codesharing on flights operated by other carriers. [202]

447.

However, the Transaction would not raise serious doubts as to its compatibility with the internal market due to these overlaps as the combined market shares on all these routes generally remain below 50%. [203]