, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force
437.

If indirect services from Heathrow were to be taken into account, the Parties combined market shares on the TS passenger segment would be [50-60]% (with an increment of [20-30]%). The next competitor would still be Saudi Arabian with a market share of [30-40]%, followed by Emirates with [0-5]%, Egyptair with [0-5]% and Lufthansa with [0-5]%. However, an indirect flight is two hours longer than a direct flight on this route. The relatively little share of TS passengers that do use indirect services on this route ([10-20]%) seems to indicate that indirect flights are a distant substitute to direct flights on this route for TS passengers. Lastly, as regards competition from indirect air services on this route, a considerable number of respondents to the market investigation (competitors, corporate customers, travel agents) indicated that they would never switch from a direct flight to an indirect flight on this route or they would only switch if direct flights were not available.

438.

Therefore, it appears that the Parties would not face a significant competitive constraint post-Transaction from competitors on the London-Riyadh route, irrespective of whether direct and indirect flights are considered on the TS passenger segment.

1.4.13. (3) NTS passengers

439.

The Parties' combined market share on the NTS passenger segment is [60-70]% with an increment of [20-30]% on Heathrow-Riyadh. Saudi Arabian Airlines is the other competitor on the NTS passenger segment on the Heathrow-Riyadh route with a market share of [30-40]%.

440.

As concerns competition from indirect air services, since one significant competitive disadvantage of indirect services relates to travel time, indirect air services are likely to exert more competitive pressure on the Parties on the NTS passenger segment than on the TS passenger segment. The market investigation indeed showed that switching is a lot more likely for NTS passengers. Most if not all of the respondents indicated that NTS passengers would switch from a direct to an indirect flight on this route in particular if there would be a price difference for the services offered. The Parties' combined market shares would decrease to [40-50]% if indirect air services from Heathrow would be included.

441.

It therefore appears that the Parties would face a significant competitive constraint both from Saudi Arabian Airlines and from other indirect flights on the NTS passenger segment on the London-Riyadh route.