[151] Indeed, the first train from London arrives at Edinburgh Waverley station at 11:25 and thus hardly allows business travellers to attend meetings starting in the morning in Edinburgh without spending the night there. East Coast train confirmed that they only operate one train in the morning and they consider this to be a small segment of the market. Furthermore, the last train that leaves London for Edinburgh is at 19h30 and the last train leaving Edinburgh for London is at 18h30 whereas flights between these cities exist until as late as 21h50 from Heathrow or 21h30 from Edinburgh.
[152] As there are no flights offered from Luton and Stansted, this section will only refer to two possible market definitions: (i) London(three)-Manchester (note that there are no flights from City) and (ii) Heathrow-Manchester.
[153] The table does not show data for London(five)-Manchester since there are no flights between Luton and Stansted and Manchester. Also note that there are no flights from City.
[154] Ibid.
[155] As explained above, the reduction in travel time by train referred to by the Parties in the Form CO, relating to the HS2 project is not relevant for the purposes of this decision.
[156] London-Manchester – quickest is 2 hours and 7 minutes (127 minutes) and Manchester-London – quickest is 1 hour and 58 minutes (118 minutes). According to the Parties, the average city centre to city centre journey time is 130 minutes.
[157] IAG considers however that this air travel time indication is in practice underestimated because it excludes certain elements such as waiting time for Heathrow Express.
[158] On the basis of 2009 data, as this was the latest year for which the Parties were able to access train data. However, the Parties estimate that the share of travel accounted for by train on this route in 2010 and 2011 are likely to be similar to – or a bit higher than the 2009 share shown above.
[159] Virgin trains did not outline existing or future likely capacity constraints on this route in a timeframe relevant for merger control review.[…]
[160] This conclusion is limited to O&D passengers only and does not refer to transfer passengers for which the Commission acknowledges that train is unlikely to constitute a significant competitive constraint.
[161] The same also holds true for services from Manchester to London.
[162] Subject to an administration fee of GBP 10.