, Commission Decision of 30/03/2012 declaring a concentration to be compatible with the co…

In force

[142] This estimate was calculated by considering the minimum duration of a flight of 85 minutes and adding 81 minutes as a minimum of time for reaching the airport. This minimum of 81 minutes for reaching the airport is based on the Parties estimate for the London-Edinburgh route for which the flight duration is a minimum of 75 minutes and the Parties estimated that the minimum city-centre to city-centre time is 156 minutes. However, as the Parties state, this is likely to be underestimated as it simply shows Heathrow Express journey time plus minimum check-in time and taxi time from the Edinburgh airport to the city centre. The distance between the Aberdeen airport and the city centre and the Edinburgh airport and the city centre is similar (seven miles for Aberdeen compared to eight miles for Edinburgh according to the airports' websites).

[143] CityJet takes on BA with Scots flights, 9 January 2012 (http://www.scotsman.com/scotland-on-sunday/business/cityjet_takes_on_ba_with_scots_flights_1_2043137)

[144] As explained above, the Commission does not consider the reduction in travel time by train relating to the HS2 project for the purposes of this decision.

[145] London-Edinburgh – quickest is 4 hours and 22 minutes (262 minutes) and Edinburgh-London – quickest is 4 hours (240 minutes). According to the Parties, the average city centre to city centre journey time is 265 minutes.

[146] London-Edinburgh – quickest is 4 hours and 51 minutes (291 minutes) and Edinburgh-London – quickest is 5 hours and 10 minutes (310 minutes).

[147] Heathrow Express is a train service linking Heathrow to the centre of London.

[148] On the basis of 2009 data, as this was the latest year for which the Parties were able to access train data. However, the Parties estimate that the share of travel accounted for by train on this route in 2010 and 2011 are likely to be similar to – or a bit higher than the 2009 share shown above.

[149] These market shares include only direct train services offered by East Coast trains.

[150] East Coast trains will introduce 3 additional services (2 southbound and 1 northbound on Sundays) between Edinburgh and London. However, these additional frequencies are unlikely to have an impact on the TS passenger segment.